Former ICE Worker Says Authorities Employees Are Being Vilified

• Deborah Fleischaker labored for the Division of Homeland Safety and ICE underneath President Biden.
• Fleischaker witnessed the Trump administration make modifications to immigration tips she labored on.
• She stated she’s feels that federal staff are being vilified and finds it unhappy to observe.

This as-told-to essay is predicated on a transcribed dialog with 52-year-old Deborah Fleischaker, from Washington, D.C. The next has been edited for size and readability.

On election evening, I knew I used to be out of a job.

I might been working for the Division of Homeland Safety as a political appointee underneath the Biden administration. I used to be hopeful about staying in my place underneath a Harris administration, however when Trump was elected, there was no query I used to be going to be leaving in January.

Political appointees serve on the route of the president, and I did not suppose President Donald Trump would ask me to remain on, or that I might keep on if requested.

I’ve at all times appreciated working for the underdog. I took my first job on the DHS in 2011. It was a departure from my background in nonprofits — I loved making an attempt to assist each the system and the folks in it.

I held a number of profession and political positions throughout the DHS till January 2025, together with because the chief of workers at Immigration and Customs Enforcement, or ICE.

Since leaving my job, I have been following updates on immigration insurance policies within the information. It has been laborious to observe modifications being made, together with to tips I used to be significantly proud to work on. I am additionally disheartened to see how — for my part — authorities workers are being vilified proper now.

I wished to assist form insurance policies in a political capability throughout my profession

I hadn’t aspired to do authorities work, nevertheless it sounded fascinating. My first function was within the Workplace for Civil Rights and Civil Liberties within the Division of Homeland Safety. I ended up loving it and stayed for nearly a decade.

I dealt with allegations of civil rights violations in DHS actions and ICE points. I labored by the primary Trump administration and wasn’t thrilled about a few of the modifications.

After the Biden administration got here in, I labored for the DHS Workplace of Coverage on insurance policies that put up guardrails round immigration enforcement close to courthouses, colleges, and medical services.

I turned the assistant director of regulatory affairs and coverage at ICE in 2021, shifting from authorities worker to political appointee, which is an ally of the celebration in energy. I’ve held political roles ever since, together with ICE’s chief of workers and chief privateness officer.

There’s an assumption that ICE workers are chilly and on one aspect of politics, however that is not my expertise. Many people had been making an attempt to do the fitting factor, even when we did not agree on what that was.

You possibly can perceive that immigration requires enforcement, together with detention and elimination, but in addition assist authorized pathways to migration. I attempted to stroll that line.

The Trump administration has rescinded a coverage I used to be significantly happy with

I am significantly happy with the guardrails round enforcement I labored on at ICE, such because the delicate areas coverage. It made me unhappy to see it reversed within the first week of the Trump administration.

I really feel that earlier administrations had been capable of implement immigration legal guidelines with the coverage in place. I do not suppose making folks scared to go to the native police, hospitals, or colleges is sweet for communities. For the reason that tips had been rescinded, there have been stories of faculty attendance dropping amongst immigrant communities.

It is laborious to observe the coverage modifications unfold as a result of I do know the blood, sweat, and tears which have gone into creating earlier insurance policies. I have been shocked by the velocity and scope of change for the reason that Trump administration got here in, though intellectually, I might have predicted a few of it.

I really feel my former colleagues in authorities jobs are being vilified

I used to be unhappy to depart my job after the election. There was a lot extra I wished to do and so some ways I assumed ICE and DHS might proceed to enhance. There are many folks within the division who I respect and can be honored to work with once more.

I might have gotten one other profession job on the DHS, however I’ve determined to work as a self-employed guide, totally on immigration. We’ll see if I prefer it.

The overwhelming majority of presidency workers are nonpartisan, hardworking people who find themselves making an attempt to do the fitting factor with taxpayer cash. However particularly now, I really feel they’re being vilified by accusations of waste, fraud, and abuse by Trump and DOGE. There are definitely modifications to the civil service I might agree with, however I believe we should always try this work rigorously and thoughtfully.

It is extremely disheartening to observe the laborious work and careers of hundreds of individuals be disparaged.

I am happy with the work I did over the previous 4 years and the relationships I’ve made all through the division, together with with folks I’ve totally different political viewpoints from.

When requested to answer Fleischaker’s statements that the White Home had abruptly reversed ICE tips, was vilifying federal staff and disparaging the laborious work and careers of hundreds of staff, a spokesperson for the White Home replied that the Biden administration’s dealing with of the US border safety was “incompetent” and “Biden officers who oversaw that four-year catastrophe don’t have any authority or standing to touch upon the Trump administration.” DOGE, ICE, and the Division of Homeland Safety didn’t reply to BI’s request for remark.

Have a tip? Contact this reporter by way of e-mail at ccheong@businessinsider.com or Sign at charissacheong.95
Use a private e-mail deal with and a nonwork gadget; here is our information to sharing data securely.